Skip to main content
(803) 521-0807 3602 Rosewood Drive, Columbia, SC 29205
Simplifying Insurance

Ready to Simplify Your Insurance?

At Keisler Insurance Group, good insurance advice starts with you—not with the cheapest quote or what a carrier wants to sell. We take the time to understand your needs, goals, and risks, then help you choose coverage that makes sense for your family or business.

Get a Quote

Start Your Quote

Get quotes and information without having to call or email. Answer a few questions and a Keisler agent takes it from there.

  • One form, not four separate quote pages.
  • We compare 20+ carriers on your behalf.
  • We only ask what we need to quote you.

Prefer to talk it through? Call (803) 521-0807 or book an appointment.

Business Insurance

As an independent insurance agency, we help small and mid-sized businesses safeguard their growth by protecting against uncertainties. Our customizable business insurance solutions offer cost savings while covering your assets, liabilities, and employees—ensuring you're prepared for the unexpected.

Right This Way >>

Personal Insurance

Personal insurance ensures financial security for you and your family by protecting your assets and covering liabilities. With the right coverage from a trusted independent insurance agency, you're prepared for unforeseen events, reducing the financial burden and providing peace of mind for the future.

Don't Be Shy >>
Core Services
The Keisler Difference

Insurance Advice That Starts With You

We are not here simply to sell you another insurance product. We are here to understand your situation, explain your options, and help you make an informed decision.

Sometimes that means recommending a different type of coverage—or explaining why a particular product or carrier may not be the right fit. And if we do not believe Keisler Insurance Group is the right agency for your needs, we will tell you and, when possible, help point you in the right direction.

When you work with us, you'll benefit from:

  • More Options With access to more than 20 carriers, we can compare coverage and pricing across multiple companies—not just offer you a single option.
  • Straightforward Advice Our recommendations are based on your needs and risks, not on what a particular carrier wants to sell.
  • A Long-Term Relationship We want to be the trusted advisor you call when you have a question, experience a major life change, or want to make sure your insurance still makes sense.
Find Out More >>
The four-person Keisler Insurance Group team, including owner Jon Keisler, standing in the colonnade of the South Carolina State House in Columbia
Jon Keisler, Owner and Agent at Keisler Insurance Group, photographed outdoors in Columbia, South Carolina
2009 Serving SC since
20+ Carriers shopped
Columbia South Carolina
About the Agency

About Keisler Insurance Group

Since 2009, Keisler Insurance Group has helped individuals, families, and businesses make informed insurance decisions. As an independent insurance agency, we work with more than 20 carriers while keeping our focus where it belongs: on our clients.

Our goal is to become more than the agency that sells you a policy. We want to be a trusted advisor you can turn to for responsive service, proactive guidance, and straightforward answers as your insurance needs change.

We're dedicated to delivering a seamless experience and the right protection for your home, car, business, and so much more.

Testimonials

Home & Auto Insurance in Columbia, SC

Why Clients Choose Us

"It has been my experience, at age 73, that an independent Insurance Agent provides the best service. The reason is simple. The client is his boss, not some Company executive, or district manager. In fact, you are his sales manager. If you don't like something about your present carrier, no worries. A good independent agent has no allegiance to a company. For a client, that allegiance becomes part of the problem. Independent means the agent represents the client, and goes to bat for you. Over many years, I have had several independent agents. The approach has worked for me. But, the best was saved for last. Jon Keisler has been a complete joy to work with. He is easily reachable, always willing to search out the best deal. He provides quick and accurate answers to questions. And, whatever the answer, it is always well researched. For my money, and hopefully for yours, Jon Keisler is the best bet for auto and home insurance."

— Joe Tonsing, Lexington, SC

We take pride in building long-term relationships with our clients, ensuring you always have an advocate in your corner.

Read More Client Testimonials >>
Claims Support

We're Here When You Need Us Most

At Keisler Insurance Group, we know that making a claim can be stressful. That's why we provide dedicated, compassionate care from real people who understand your situation.

You won't be left waiting on hold for hours or navigating through an endless maze of automated responses. Instead, you'll receive expert advice and prompt, personalized service, ensuring your claim is handled efficiently and with care.

Get Started

Reach out today to get started.

Get a Quote Now >>
Carrier logo Carrier logo Carrier logo Carrier logo Carrier logo Carrier logo Carrier logo
Newsletter

Stay in the Know

Get seasonal coverage tips and local insurance news from Keisler Insurance Group — no spam, just useful stuff.